Ribbonfarm Studio

Share this post

The Next Silicon Valley

studio.ribbonfarm.com

The Next Silicon Valley

Venkatesh Rao
Aug 21, 2015
Share this post

The Next Silicon Valley

studio.ribbonfarm.com

Every conversation about technology and innovation eventually turns to the "Next Silicon Valley" question and prospects for some seemingly promising second-tier hub. This conversation belongs in the Not-Even-Wrong category. The idea of the "Next Silicon Valley" is simply the spatial version of the "Next Big Thing": a kind of wishful thinking that romantically yearns for a new, pristine frontier. But the real prospects for non-Silicon-Valley software technology regions are actually brighter if you drop Silicon-Valley-envy as a frame. Why?

(p.s. This is an illustrated newsletter, turn on image display!)

View this email in your browser

The Next Silicon Valley Ultimate Wrestling Championship. Illustration by Grace Witherell.

1/ I have lived in 5 "Next Silicon Valley" (NSV) wannabe cities: Bangalore, Austin, Washington DC, Seattle, and Las Vegas.

2/ Four deserve "A for effort" even though their startup scenes still pale relative to Silicon Valley. The 5th, Las Vegas, is a joke.

3/ Around the world, most such efforts are abject failures. Even if 1-2 big successes emerge, an SV-scale startup scene does not take root.

4/ NSV projects tend to be based on one of 3 terrible theories: culture begets economics (CbE), Cold War redux (CwR), Next Big Thing (NBT)

5/ CbE is the idea that a great music scene, cafes and coworking spaces create a tech scene. This theory confuses cause and effect.

6/ CwR is the idea that mimicking Cold War history - radar, missiles - can do the trick. This confuses history rhyming for history repeating

7/ NBT is the theory that some other technology, say biotech, can do for region X what software did for Silicon Valley.

8/ All three are wishful fantasies. When I hear such theories, I fell like yelling AARGH! TECH EVOLUTION DOES NOT WORK THAT WAY!

9/ Technology evolves in layers, like geological strata. Each world-eating technology adds a layer and builds on the previous one.

10/ "Eating" revolutions are special and rare. They radiate out from just 1-2 epicenters and cover the ENTIRE world over 50-100 years.

11/ The "Last Silicon Valley" was the 1870s-90s mass manufacturing revolution that radiated out from New York and the Connecticut Valley.

12/ There can be no "Next Silicon Valley" for a while because you cannot repeat an eating revolution or do-over from a different epicenter.

13/ Neither can you cut ongoing revolution short because you have macroeconomic ADD. You have to play game that's on, not game you want.

14/ There is unlikely to be a "Next Silicon Valley" for at least 50 years because it'll take 2-3 generations to absorb the impact of this one.

15/ So long as majority of potential of software eating the world remains untapped, all technology hubs will be shaped by SV gravity field

16/ Shenzen is an example. It is not a "Next Silicon Valley," but neither is it a "First Shenzen." It is shaped by (and shapes) Silicon Valley.

17/ Shenzen is neither a substitute for SV, nor independent of it, but a younger complement. A child node in an evolutionary-explosion tree.

18/ A pair of concepts from political science, "pristine state formation" and "competitive state formation" help explain how this evolution works.

19/ When virgin territory is colonized by humans, the first states that emerge are pristine states. They are shaped by natural constraints.

20/ Once a territory is occupied, new states emerge that are shaped not by natural constraints, but filial competition with existing states.

21/ Silicon Valley was shaped by the nature of semiconductors, and shaped the world. It is a pristine state that occupies the world.

22/ Shenzen and other hubs have been/are being shaped more by the presence and power of Silicon Valley than by Moore's Law directly.

23/ How will the geography of s/w evolve in the future? The history of New York/Connecticut Valley provides clues.

24/ As manufacturing matured, New York turned into a financial capital and technology work moved first to Midwest, then Europe, then Asia.

25/ In the process it was commoditized. Today's geography of manufacturing is shaped by proximity to unskilled labor, raw materials, markets

26/ As pristine innovation slows, these proximity factors offer increasing advantages and activity shifts in response.

27/ In the process, customer-driven or supply-driven companies rise, pristine-innovation driven companies decline.

28/ But while pristine innovation dominates, advantage is with regions with high concentration of creative labor and financial capital.

29/ s/w is unlike manufacturing in 2 ways: One, there seems to be no natural plateau beyond which proximity factors trump product innovation

30/ Two, human creativity is the dominant raw material. Not counting electricity for data centers, there is no other supply to "control".

31/ SV's advantage lies in its ability to unleash, not minor trickles, but huge floods of talent at product scaling opportunities.

32/ SV is like a hydraulic empire of human talent. Instead of Egyptian pyramids, we get unicorn companies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydraulic_empire

33/ So-called "unicorns" -- high-value companies with very high market-cap-to-labor ratios -- require large, liquid talent pools to grow.

34/ They also require an ecosystem of market-makers, such as experienced angel investor, recirculating tech scaling experts, universities.

35/ Other hubs can get there, but not through naive formulas like CbE, CwR and NBT. Talent liquidity at scale is not THAT easy to achieve.

36/ As virtual collaboration, VR tech improves, entirely virtual hubs will also join the fray. The second tier is going to get interesting.

37/ The role of "pioneer" has already been claimed by SV, but there are plenty of roles to be filled in the software-eating-world drama.

38/ Make no mistake: some of these roles may be less sexy and lack pioneer bragging rights, but might be MORE economically valuable.

39/ Reaching towards your region's unique software destiny is the game of regions breaking smart. Stop wasting time on SV-envy.

40/ How do you get there? For starters, read http://breakingsmart.com if you haven't already.

_Check out Breaking Smart Season 1 for the deeper context behind this newsletter. If you're interested in bringing the Season 1 workshop to your organization, get in touch. You can follow me on Twitter @vgr

And don't forget to share this newsletter to people who might find it useful._

Copyright © 2015 Ribbonfarm Consulting, LLC, All rights reserved.

Share this post

The Next Silicon Valley

studio.ribbonfarm.com
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Venkatesh Rao
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing